singer sewing machine vs brother sewing machine

A Background on Singer and Brother Sewing Machine Brands

Singer is a well-known name in the sewing industry that has been around since 1851, with Singer sewing machines being one of the oldest. The Singer brand built its reputation on innovative features, easy-to-use designs, and reliable performance. Over the years, Singer has paved the way for many advancements in sewing technology.

Brother entered the home sewing machine market much later, in the 1960s. Since then, the Japanese company has grown into one of the top three sewing machine brands worldwide. Brother stands out for manufacturing feature-rich, budget-friendly machines tailored for home sewers. The brand frequently updates its line with the latest technology.

Singer and Brother have robust reputations for quality sewing machines, from essential to computerized. However, the two brands position themselves a bit differently. Singer promotes its longstanding sewing heritage and history of innovation. Brother markets itself as a feature-packed, affordable brand for the everyday sewer.

Now let’s compare some critical factors between Singer and Brother sewing machines.

When deciding between Singer and Brother, there are several variables you’ll want to compare:

Pricing

Brother sewing machines are more budget-friendly for the features offered. Under $150, you can get the Brother CS6000i, which comes with 60 built-in stitches, a wide table, and an automatic needle threader. Singer machines at this low price point typically have fewer features.

However, Singer has affordable options under $200, like the Singer Start 1304. Singer’s mid-range to high-end models can match or exceed Brother’s pricing.

Features

Brother sewing machines often boast more built-in stitches, varying from 60 to 600+ on computerized machines. Many include specialty stitches for quilting, heirloom sewing, and embroidery.

Singer offers excellent features but fewer decorative stitches than Brother at comparable price points. However, Singer machines excel at everyday stitches and buttonholes. High-end Singers have stitch editing capabilities.

Brother generally offers more automated functions for computerized sewing machines, like needle threading and thread trimming. Singer focuses more on the ease of selecting stitches and settings.

Both brands offer user-friendly push-button features and intuitive controls. For embroidery, Brother has a slight edge with more embroidery field options.

Build Quality

Build Quality
Photo credit: pexels

Brother uses plastic bodies and frames on their lower-end machines, with metal frames on mid-range and heavier-duty models. Singer uses metal frames across more of their line, even on affordable models like the Singer 2250.

Many reviewers agree both brands have good build quality and durability in their respective price ranges. For heavy-duty sewing, top-end machines from both companies have potent motors and metal frames.

Ease of Use

Singer and Brother manufacture sewing machines that are suitable for beginners and experts alike. Brother offers a wide range of computerized models with automatic features. Singer has dial selections and settings ideal for new sewers.

Brother’s LCD screens and push button controls provide excellent ease of use. Singer aims for simplicity with easy stitch selection. Lower-end Singer models may require manual adjustments like thread tension.

Both brands include thorough manuals and warranties. Singer offers more free technical support resources like videos. Brother manuals are very detailed.

Customer Support

Singer and Brother provide customer assistance through email, live chat, and phone, as they are mainly an internet-based company. Singer provides tutorials, a knowledge base, and an online sewing community for help.

Most reviewers praise both brands for having responsive, helpful customer service. Brother’s warranty tends to be longer (5-25 years) versus Singer’s (5 years). Authorized dealers can assist with service and repairs after the warranty.

Top Model Showdown: Singer vs Brother

How do some of the best-selling and top-rated Singer and Brother models compare? Let’s pit two popular machines head to head.

Singer Quantum Stylist 9960 vs Brother CS6000i

The Singer 9960 and Brother CS6000i are two computerized sewing machines packed with features.

  • The Singer 9960 boasts 600 built-in stitches, a large embroidery field, auto needle threading, and a heavy-duty metal interior frame. It includes 18 presser feet for specialty techniques. Price: $400
  •  The Brother CS6000i offers 60 built-in stitches, 70 embroidery designs, automatic needle threading, an easy-to-navigate LCD screen, and a 25-year limited warranty. Price: $150

The Singer 9960 is the clear winner for features and performance, justifying its higher price tag. The CS6000i offers incredible value at a budget-friendly cost, but the Singer’s expanded stitch capabilities, sturdier build, and larger embroidery field make it the superior machine.

Singer Heavy Duty 4411 vs Brother ST371HD

Want a powerful machine for sewing thicker fabrics? The Singer 4411 and Brother ST371HD both fit the heavy-duty category.

  • The Singer 4411 has an all-metal interior frame, a powerful motor to sew 1,100 stitches per minute, and can easily sew denim and canvas. It includes a metal foot pedal. Price: $199.99
  •  The Brother ST371HD features a metal interior frame, metal needle plate, 70 built-in stitches, an automatic needle threader, a jam-resistant drop-in bobbin, and a motor that can sew 1100 stitches per minute. Price: $169.99

For price and performance, the Brother ST371HD takes the win. It offers power and durability similar to the Singer 4411 for $30 less. The Brother includes more features like the needle threader and built-in stitches. Either machine will easily handle heavy-duty projects, but the ST371HD provides a better bang for your buck.

Which Brand is Better for Your Needs?

While similarities exist between Singer and Brother sewing machines, each brand caters better to specific needs and budgets.

For beginners: Brother

Brother machines live up to their reputation as feature-packed but easy for beginners. The XM2701 and CS6000i have user-friendly controls, LCD screens, built-in stitches, and automatic functions.

The Singer is also suitable for beginners and significantly lower-end models with simple dials like the Simple 3223. But many Singers require more manual adjustments.

For quilting and embroidery: Brother

Brother sewing machines have larger embroidery fields, more built-in embroidery designs, and quilting stitches. Good options include the SE600, PE770, and DreamWeaver.

Singer embroidery machines like the Quantum Stylist 9960 are capable but with smaller hoops. The Singer quilting machines offer excellent stitch performance.

For heavy-duty: Tie

Brother and Singer produces excellent heavy-duty machines that can sew through thick materials like the Brother ST371HD and Singer Heavy Duty 4411.

For computerized features: Brother

Brother has cheaper models with automated features like needle threading and thread cutting, especially in their computerized sewing machine line.

The Singer does have very advanced computerized machines but fewer family-friendly models with all the automated bells and whistles.

For budget buyers: Brother

Good Brother machines like the CS6000i and XM2701 offer a lot of value and features for under $200. Lower-priced Singer models tend to have fewer features.

However, in the $100 to $150 range, Singer also has competitive models like the Simple 3232 and Heavy Duty 4423.

FAQs:

What is the main difference between Singer and Brother sewing machines?

Singer has a more extended history and reputation for innovation, while Brother offers more features and stitches for more affordable prices. Singer focuses on ease of use, and Brother provides more automated functions.

Which brand is better for beginners – Singer or Brother?

Brother sewing machines are typically better for beginners, as they offer more user-friendly features and intuitive controls. Models like the Brother CS6000i have settings and LCD screens that are ideal for new sewers.

Which sewing machine brand is better for embroidery – Singer or Brother?

Most reviewers agree that Brother sewing machines offer better performance for embroidery, with more built-in embroidery designs and larger maximum hoop sizes. The Brother SE600 or PE770 would be great choices.

Is a Singer or Brother better for heavy-duty sewing?

Both Singer and Brother produce heavy-duty machines capable of sewing through thick fabrics. The Singer Heavy Duty 4411 and Brother ST371HD are two excellent heavy-duty options.

Which brand offers more affordable sewing machines?

Brother tends to have more budget-friendly options under $200, while Singer’s affordable machines are more in the $200 to $300 range. Shoppers on a tight budget may favor Brother.

Which sewing machines have better customer support – Singer or Brother?

Singer and Brother receive positive customer support and warranty reviews. Singer offers video tutorials and an online community, while Brother provides detailed instruction manuals.

Is one sewing machine brand longer-lasting or more durable?

Durability depends more on the individual model specs than the brand name. Singer and Brother have machines with all-metal frames and parts that can last decades with proper maintenance.

Conclusion: Which Brand Comes Out on Top?

So, is Singer or Brother better? Singer has the edge regarding reputation, history, and innovations. When it comes to affordable pricing, versatility, and features – Brother excels.

Ultimately, there is no definitive winner. The best brand depends on your specific sewing needs and budget. Here are a few key takeaways:

  • Brother machines are packed with more features and stitches for less money. They win for overall value.
  •  The Singer boasts time-tested quality and intuitive controls. The brand offers streamlined functionality.
  •  For computerized sewing, Brother dominates with their user-friendly models.
  •  Singer holds the advantage of excellent everyday stitches and buttonholes.
  •  Both brands perform well for heavy-duty sewing and have exceptional customer support.

While Brother takes the slight lead overall, we recommend researching the specific machine model you’re interested in rather than judging solely based on the brand name. Try them in person. And consider what features matter most to your projects. With proper care, Singer and Brother sewing machines can provide many years of sewing enjoyment.

What’s Your Take – Are You Team Singer or Team Brother?

Now that you know how Singer and Brother compare, which brand do you prefer? Share your experiences and weigh in with which company makes the best sewing machines. We’d love to hear your thoughts!

***

Main image: freepik

Priti Nandy
Priti Nandy
Articles: 168

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *